AmTrust Financial vs The Hartford
An honest side-by-side comparison of two of our top workers comp insurance picks — pricing, strengths, weaknesses, and who each one is really for.
AmTrust Financial
Ranked #4 of 15 in this directory
Specialized small business workers comp with fast online quoting and approval
The Hartford
Ranked #1 of 15 in this directory
One of the most trusted workers comp insurers for small and mid-sized businesses
Our pick: The Hartford. Our editors rank The Hartford higher overall in Workers Comp Insurance — but AmTrust Financial can be the better fit depending on your budget and use case below. How we review
Compare the details
| AmTrust Financial | The Hartford | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Paid | Paid |
| Starting price | See website | See website |
| Category | Restaurant | Small Business |
| Editorial rank | #4 of 15 | #1 of 15 |
Strengths
AmTrust Financial
- ✓Specializes in small accounts that larger carriers may decline or price too high
- ✓Fast online quoting and approval for many standard business classes
- ✓TrustOnline portal provides real-time access to policies and claims
- ✓Competitive pricing for restaurants, retail, and professional services
- ✓Strong A.M. Best financial strength rating
The Hartford
- ✓Over 200 years of insurance experience with deep workers comp expertise
- ✓Pay-as-you-go billing tied to actual payroll eliminates end-of-year audits
- ✓Dedicated nurse case managers speed up employee recovery and return to work
- ✓Coverage available for over 400 different business types and industries
- ✓Strong online portal for certificates, claims tracking, and policy management
Watch out for
AmTrust Financial
- !Customer service quality has received mixed reviews in some markets
- !Not ideal for large or complex accounts that require dedicated underwriting attention
- !Claims resolution speed can vary by state and injury type
- !Limited availability in some states for certain business classes
The Hartford
- !Premiums can be higher than newer digital-first insurers for low-risk businesses
- !Not available as a direct purchase — requires going through an agent in many states
- !Some policyholders report slower claims resolution for complex cases
- !Bundling discounts are limited compared to larger carriers
Best use cases
AmTrust Financial
- →Restaurant owner needing affordable workers comp for kitchen and wait staff
- →Small retailer that larger carriers have declined or overpriced
- →New business needing fast online workers comp approval with minimal paperwork
The Hartford
- →Small business owner wanting a trusted carrier with a long track record
- →Employer seeking pay-as-you-go workers comp billing to match cash flow
- →Business with injured workers needing proactive return-to-work programs
About each tool
AmTrust Financial
AmTrust Financial Services is a leading specialty insurer focused heavily on small businesses, offering workers compensation as its flagship product. AmTrust is known for competitive pricing on small accounts that larger carriers often overlook, fast online application and approval, and a streamlined claims process. The company serves over 30 industries and is particularly strong for retail, restaurants, and professional services. AmTrust's TrustOnline portal provides employers with real-time access to certificates, policies, and claims status.
The Hartford
The Hartford is a leading provider of workers compensation insurance with over 200 years in the industry. Known for its strong claims management and return-to-work programs, The Hartford helps businesses reduce costs by getting injured employees back on the job quickly. The company offers flexible pay-as-you-go billing tied to actual payroll, an intuitive online portal for policy management, and industry-specific programs for over 400 business types. Its dedicated nurse case managers and vocational rehabilitation services set it apart from competitors for businesses that prioritize employee recovery outcomes.
Still deciding? Browse all 15 options with honest pros, cons, and pricing.
See all Workers Comp Insurance →